Opening a pension statement and seeing that the value has fallen can be unsettling. If retirement is approaching—or you are already taking an income—the natural reaction may be to move the money, stop contributing or withdraw it before the position becomes worse.
However, a fall in value does not automatically mean that your retirement plan has failed. Most defined-contribution pensions are long-term investments, so their value will move as financial markets rise and fall. What matters is what you own, when you expect to use the money and whether withdrawals are already being made.
Understanding your pension during a market downturn can help you separate a temporary movement from a problem that genuinely needs attention.
Why can a pension fall when the stock market falls?
A defined-contribution pension is normally invested in one or more funds. Those funds may hold shares in companies, government and corporate bonds, property, cash and other assets. If the prices of the underlying investments fall, the value shown on your pension statement will usually fall too.
Different pension funds can behave very differently. A fund with a high proportion in global shares may experience larger short-term changes than one holding more bonds or cash. Yet lower-volatility investments are not risk-free: bond prices can fall, cash can lose spending power to inflation and concentrating too heavily in one area can create its own risks.
Diversification aims to avoid relying on a single market or type of investment. It cannot prevent every loss, but it can reduce the effect of one area performing badly. Before reacting to a headline about “the market”, check which markets and assets your pension actually holds.
A defined-benefit pension works differently. It normally promises an income calculated under the scheme’s rules rather than giving you an individual investment pot. Day-to-day stock-market movements do not usually alter the pension income already promised, although the scheme itself will still invest assets to meet its obligations.
Your stage of retirement makes a difference
For someone who is still many years from retirement and making regular contributions, a downturn may be uncomfortable without requiring an immediate change. Contributions made while fund prices are lower buy more units. If markets later recover, those additional units can participate in the recovery—although neither the timing nor the extent of any recovery is guaranteed.
The position becomes more sensitive when retirement is close. A substantial fall shortly before a planned withdrawal can reduce the amount available to provide tax-free cash or income. It may also expose a mismatch between the investments held and the way the pension is going to be used.
Some pension providers gradually alter investments as a selected retirement date approaches. This is often called “lifestyling”. The strategy may have been designed for somebody who intends to buy an annuity, take cash or enter drawdown at a particular date. If your plans have changed, the default approach may no longer fit. That is a reason to review it—not to assume that automatically moving everything into cash is the answer.
Why withdrawals can make a downturn more damaging
If your pension remains invested while you take an income through drawdown, withdrawals usually involve selling investments. When prices are depressed, more units may need to be sold to produce the same amount of cash. Those units are no longer present to benefit if markets later recover.
This is often called sequencing risk. The order in which gains and losses occur can affect how long a drawdown fund lasts, even where two people achieve a similar average return over the full period. Poor returns in the first years of retirement, combined with continuing withdrawals, can be particularly difficult to recover from.
Imagine two people each begin retirement with the same pension and take the same annual income. One experiences stronger markets first and weaker markets later; the other encounters the downturn at the beginning. The second person may have to sell more units while values are low, leaving a smaller amount invested for the eventual recovery. This is only an illustration, but it shows why an income plan needs to consider more than an assumed average growth rate.
Drawdown income is not guaranteed. The amount taken, investment performance, inflation, charges and how long the income is needed will all influence whether the fund remains sustainable.
Should you switch funds or withdraw your pension?
A sudden switch after markets have fallen can turn a fall on paper into a permanent loss. It may also mean missing a later recovery. That does not mean an investment should never be changed. It means the decision should be based on whether the strategy is still suitable, rather than an attempt to escape yesterday’s news.
Withdrawing the pension simply to remove it from the market can have wider consequences. A taxable withdrawal may increase your Income Tax bill, reduce the amount left to support later life and trigger restrictions on future pension contributions. Money moved into a bank account may also lose value to inflation, while interest above the relevant allowances could be taxable.
Before acting, establish what has actually changed. Has only the market moved, or have your retirement date, income needs, health, family circumstances or attitude to risk changed too? A portfolio that was unsuitable before a downturn does not become suitable by waiting, but a suitable long-term plan should not normally be abandoned solely because investments have had a difficult period.
What if you are already taking pension drawdown?
A market fall is a useful prompt to review the whole income plan. Depending on your circumstances, the discussion might include whether withdrawals can vary, whether essential spending is covered by secure income and how much accessible cash is available for near-term needs.
Some people choose to hold a cash reserve so that every expense does not require an investment sale during weak markets. The right amount is personal: too little may provide limited protection, while too much can reduce long-term growth and expose more money to inflation.
It may also be possible to reduce non-essential withdrawals temporarily, draw from a different source or use different parts of a diversified portfolio. These are planning considerations, not universal instructions. Using savings first can affect interest, tax, benefits and emergency resilience, while changing which investments are sold can alter the risk of the remaining portfolio.
If regular income is essential and uncertainty is uncomfortable, it may be worth discussing whether some pension savings should provide guaranteed income through an annuity. Annuity terms depend on age, health, options selected and market rates, and the purchase is normally difficult or impossible to reverse.
Should you stop pension contributions when markets fall?
Stopping contributions after a fall can mean missing the opportunity to buy fund units at lower prices. It may also mean losing employer contributions and tax relief. On the other hand, keeping up unaffordable contributions at the expense of priority bills or expensive debt may not be sensible.
The decision should be based on household cash flow and the suitability of the pension, not a prediction about when the market will reach its lowest point. Consistently identifying the bottom and the recovery is extremely difficult. If you are considering reducing contributions, check what your employer pays, what benefits are attached to the scheme and how the change would affect your retirement target.
Questions to ask before making a change
A calm review should help you answer:
- Is the pension defined contribution or defined benefit?
- Which funds and asset types are held, and how diversified are they?
- How much has the pension fallen over the relevant period, after contributions and withdrawals are taken into account?
- When will the money actually be needed?
- Will it fund a one-off purchase, flexible drawdown or a guaranteed income?
- Are withdrawals being taken while investments are down?
- How much essential spending is covered by the State Pension, a defined-benefit pension or an annuity?
- Is there an appropriate cash reserve outside or within the retirement plan?
- Do the existing investments still match your capacity and willingness to accept risk?
- Would a switch create charges, tax consequences or the loss of guarantees?
Cash-flow modelling can test how different withdrawals, retirement dates and market conditions might affect the plan. It cannot predict future returns, but it can show where the outcome relies on optimistic assumptions or has little room for setbacks.
A downturn calls for a review, not a reflex
Seeing a pension fall is never pleasant. The important distinction is between reacting to short-term market movement and making a considered change because your investments no longer suit the job the money needs to do.
If retirement is years away, time and continued contributions may be important parts of the plan. If retirement is close, the investment route and intended withdrawals need closer attention. If income has already started, the interaction between market returns and withdrawals should be reviewed regularly.
Westfield Financial Solutions can help bring your wider financial position into focus. For pension, investment and retirement advice, Westfield refers clients to Lakeside FS Ltd. You may also find our guides to the five-year retirement countdown, retiring with a £250,000 pension pot and phased retirement useful.
To discuss your wider financial planning, call 01274 036 888, email info@westfieldfs.co.uk or contact Westfield Financial Solutions.
Important information: This article is for general information only and does not constitute personalised pension, investment, financial or tax advice. Pension and tax rules can change and their effect depends on individual circumstances. The value of investments and any income from them can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you invest. Pension drawdown income is not guaranteed. Pension benefits are normally inaccessible until the applicable minimum pension age.
0 Comments